Personally, I have always like the handling of Bridgestone's upper end tires over everything else that I've tried. I haven't tried the Goodyear Eagle F1s yet, but would like to. As for the others that I've tried, here's how I would rank them...
2. Toyo Proxes T1s (almost as good as Bridgestone S-03)
3. Michelin Pilot Sport (too much $$, too short tread life, but otherwise awesome!)
4. Yokohama AVS Sport (Too short tread life, not as good in rain as above)
5. Kumho (great tire for the price, only two 19" sizes tho)
6. Dunlop Sport 9000 (average, prefer above tires for same or lower $$)
7. Contis (good comfort, less performance)
8. Pirelli (quit trying this brand after I couldn't get last set to balance)